Your Landing Page Isn’t the Problem, Your Offer Is

Hey friends, Jay Myers here from Shopify 1%, where we chase daily 1% wins so your Shopify store can grow 37x by the end of the year. Yes, 37x. That’s not hype. That’s math. Compounding is real, and it’s your best friend in ecommerce.

In today’s episode, I tackled a topic that’s quietly wrecking conversion rates across Shopify stores. And no, it’s not your headline font or your hero image.

Your landing page isn’t broken. Your offer is.

What’s an “Offer,” Anyway?

I don’t mean your price tag or a last-minute discount code. I’m talking about the complete value proposition. What exactly are people getting? Why should they buy right now? What’s in it for them?

An offer isn’t just "$79.99 and good vibes."

It’s:

• Buy 2, get 1 free.
• Comes with a free shaker bottle.
• Try it for 60 days, no risk.
• Includes a lifetime warranty.
• Get it today, not next week.
  

A Great Offer Beats a Great Landing Page

Let’s drop a truth bomb.

According to MEC Labs, 60% of a customer’s decision to buy is based on the offer, while only 20% is driven by landing page design. That’s right. You could be obsessing over button size or color palette while your competitors, who have average-looking pages but killer offers, are running laps around you. A great landing page won’t save a weak offer. But a great offer can absolutely save a basic-looking page. You don’t need a Pulitzer Prize-winning headline. You need a real reason for someone to click “buy now.”

What Makes a Great Shopify Offer?

Here’s a cheat code for ecommerce. The best offers I’ve seen almost always hit at least two of the following, ideally all three.

1. Value Stack

Don’t just sell a product. Sell a package. Make the customer feel like they’re getting a deal that’s too good to pass up.

Example:

• Shaker bottle (worth $29.99)
• Nutrition plan PDF ($49)
• Bonus T-shirt ($59)
• Private community access (priceless... sort of)
  

Total value: $187. Your price: $79.

Keep it believable. The magic ratio is about 3 to 4 times the perceived value vs price. When it feels too inflated, people get suspicious.

2. Urgency or Scarcity

People procrastinate. It’s your job to move them off the fence.

Use:

• "Only 3 left"
• "Ends tonight at midnight"
• "Limited to the first 50 orders"
  

According to CXL, adding urgency increased conversions by 332%. That is not a typo.

3. Risk Reversal

Remove any excuse not to buy.

Options:

• 60-day money-back guarantee
• Free trial
• Lifetime warranty
• “Just pay shipping” for sample offers

Make it so risk-free they’d feel silly saying no.

Shopify Stats You Should Know

Let’s back all this up with some data:

• Bundling can increase average order value and conversions by up to 40%
• Urgency-based messaging has shown conversion lifts of 300% or more
• The offer itself drives 60% of purchase decisions compared to just 20% for landing page design
  

If you’re going to optimize anything, start with your offer.

Here’s Your 1% Win Today

Log into Shopify. Look at your three best-selling products. Now ask yourself this: Is the offer clear and compelling? Or are you just listing the price and hoping for the best? Start stacking value. Add urgency. Reverse the risk. This is where the magic happens.

Quick Bonus: Lifetime Warranty Hack

One brand I admire offers a lifetime warranty on sunglasses.

Here’s the breakdown:

• Product cost: $5
  
• Selling price: $29
  
• If a customer redeems the warranty, they pay $6.99 for shipping
  

Only a small percentage of buyers ever redeem it, and the company still makes money on the replacements.

Result: higher perceived value, higher conversion rate, and more trust. Win. Win. Win.

Shopify Offer Checklist

Use this as your new standard:

• Is there a clear value stack?
• Is there urgency or scarcity?
• Have you included a risk-reversal component?
  

If yes, you’ve probably got a strong offer.

If not, this is your next growth lever. Don’t tweak another pixel or font until your offer passes this test.